Pros

  • Located in the Florida Keys, right on the ocean
  • Lots of activities available
  • Two on-site bars, also with live entertainment
  • Two on-site restaurants
  • Large swimming pool and hot tub with panoramic water views
  • Pets allowed for a fee
  • Rooms have flat-screen TVs, coffeemakers, and iPod docks
  • Freebies include self-parking and Wi-Fi
See More Pros

Cons

  • Every reservation has mandatory resort fee
  • Old bathrooms in some rooms
  • Some complaints about state of linens and towels
  • Area can get rowdy with college vacationers
  • Weddings can overcrowd the beach
  • No free breakfast
See More Cons

Bottom Line

Located in Islamorada, Postcard Inn is a 150-room mid-range hotel that sits right on the water in the middle of the Florida Keys. There's lots to do on the property, with multiple dining options, happy hour with live music, boating and water-related sports, and family-friendly activities. The inn’s rates are competitive and similar to nearby hotels in the same category. Though much of the property has updated, contemporary nautical themes, some rooms, particularly bathrooms, could use further renovations.

See More Bottom Line

Amenities

  • Cribs
  • Internet
  • Pets Allowed
  • Pool

Oyster Hotel Review

Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

Scene

A mid-range waterfront hotel with nautical decor and drinking/eating options

Postcard Inn is located in Islamorada, also dubbed the “sport fishing capital of the world.” Situated directly off of Overseas Highway, this waterfront hotel has been transformed from a ‘50s-style motel into an updated mid-range resort. An impressive complex, the hotel features rooms spread out between several buildings.

The inn has updated the design in the public areas and guest rooms from Florida kitsch to contemporary nautical themes. Decor throughout the property includes dark woods, driftwood detailing, light-colored walls, and splashes of blue and green ocean hues. Guest rooms present fish art, driftwood furniture, and tropical curtains, and some rooms feature a clear view of the Atlantic Ocean or the marina. There’s also a lagoon-style pool and a neatly manicured beach with white-and-yellow lounge chairs.

See More Scene

Location

Located on the laid-back island of Islamorada in the middle of the Keys

Postcard Inn sits on the waterfront near Overseas Highway, with access to a marina and Whale Harbor. Most travelers to the Middle Keys find it necessary to rent a car, as restaurants and shopping are quite spread out. Located within short driving distance to the north and south, respectively, the Theater of the Sea offers aquatic shows while Robbie's Marina offers visitors the chance to feed the tarpon. Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, five minutes away, is also known to have some of the best Key lime pie around.

See More Location

Rooms

Rooms are updated and some have amazing views, but bathrooms could still use major work

Rooms range from standard studios with queen beds to two-bedroom oceanfront suites with a kitchen. Spaces with the best views are located in buildings 100 or 200. Rooms have standard furnishings, plus mini-fridges, iPod docks, flat-screen TVs, and free Wi-Fi. Bathrooms in some of the smaller spaces have been the subject of guests’ complaints and could use an upgrade -- some have aging bath tubs, peeling paint, and other issues asking for attention.

See More Rooms

Features

From paddleboarding to boat rentals, this hotel has a ton of family-friendly activities, with dining options on hand as well

On-site restaurants and bars include the World Famous Tiki Bar with live music performances and happy-hour specials, the steak and seafood spot Shula's 2, and Jaws Raw Bar, with fresh oysters and a killer view. Paddleboards, jet skis, kayaks, and more are available for rent at the marina. Longer aquatic adventures can be booked through the hotel, like snorkeling trips, eco-tours, and diving. There’s a large oceanfront swimming pool on the property and a private beach with chairs and umbrellas. A bright green arcade room features games and activities for kids.

See More Features

Things You Should Know About Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

Also Known As

  • Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina at Holiday Isle

Address

84001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, Florida 33036-3408, United States

Website

Oyster Hotel Review

Postcard Inn Beach Resort & Marina

Scene

A mid-range waterfront hotel with nautical decor and drinking/eating options

Postcard Inn is located in Islamorada, also dubbed the “sport fishing capital of the world.” Situated directly off of Overseas Highway, this waterfront hotel has been transformed from a ‘50s-style motel into an updated mid-range resort. An impressive complex, the hotel features rooms spread out between several buildings.

The inn has updated the design in the public areas and guest rooms from Florida kitsch to contemporary nautical themes. Decor throughout the property includes dark woods, driftwood detailing, light-colored walls, and splashes of blue and green ocean hues. Guest rooms present fish art, driftwood furniture, and tropical curtains, and some rooms feature a clear view of the Atlantic Ocean or the marina. There’s also a lagoon-style pool and a neatly manicured beach with white-and-yellow lounge chairs.

See More Scene

Location

Located on the laid-back island of Islamorada in the middle of the Keys

Postcard Inn sits on the waterfront near Overseas Highway, with access to a marina and Whale Harbor. Most travelers to the Middle Keys find it necessary to rent a car, as restaurants and shopping are quite spread out. Located within short driving distance to the north and south, respectively, the Theater of the Sea offers aquatic shows while Robbie's Marina offers visitors the chance to feed the tarpon. Lorelei Restaurant & Cabana Bar, five minutes away, is also known to have some of the best Key lime pie around.

See More Location

Rooms

Rooms are updated and some have amazing views, but bathrooms could still use major work

Rooms range from standard studios with queen beds to two-bedroom oceanfront suites with a kitchen. Spaces with the best views are located in buildings 100 or 200. Rooms have standard furnishings, plus mini-fridges, iPod docks, flat-screen TVs, and free Wi-Fi. Bathrooms in some of the smaller spaces have been the subject of guests’ complaints and could use an upgrade -- some have aging bath tubs, peeling paint, and other issues asking for attention.

See More Rooms

Features

From paddleboarding to boat rentals, this hotel has a ton of family-friendly activities, with dining options on hand as well

On-site restaurants and bars include the World Famous Tiki Bar with live music performances and happy-hour specials, the steak and seafood spot Shula's 2, and Jaws Raw Bar, with fresh oysters and a killer view. Paddleboards, jet skis, kayaks, and more are available for rent at the marina. Longer aquatic adventures can be booked through the hotel, like snorkeling trips, eco-tours, and diving. There’s a large oceanfront swimming pool on the property and a private beach with chairs and umbrellas. A bright green arcade room features games and activities for kids.

See More Features

Best Rates

Amenities

  • Air Conditioner

  • Airport Transportation

  • Beach

  • Business Center

  • Cabanas

  • Cable

  • Cribs

  • Dry Cleaning

  • Full Kitchen

  • Gameroom / Arcade

  • Internet

  • Kids Allowed

  • Laundry

  • Meeting / Conference Rooms

  • Pets Allowed

  • Pool

  • Poolside Drink Service

  • Room Service

  • Separate Bedroom / Living Room Space

Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.