Best Value Hotels in Times Square

A team of Oyster reporters spent weeks exploring 193 hotels in New York. We slept in the beds, ate in the restaurants, tested the service, and lounged by the pools, all with an eye toward selecting the most distinguished properties. Here's a list of the best hotels for the buck in Times Square.

Best Western PLUS President Hotel at Times Square

1.

Best Western PLUS President Hotel at Times Square Rating: 3.0 Pearls

Categories: Value

The Best Western underwent a full renovation in September '09 and has some of the lowest rates in Times Square. The clean rooms have flat-screen TVs, free Wi-Fi, brand-new appliances, and a new look that's reminiscent of an Urban Outfitters clothing store.

Broadway at Times Square Hotel

2.

Broadway at Times Square Hotel Rating: 2.5 Pearls

Categories: Business

An excellent location and up-to-date (if snug) rooms make the Comfort Inn a deal. It's situated on a safe, quiet street just a half-block from Time Square's buzz and a short walk from Central Park and Rockefeller Center. Plus, all its rooms have flatscreens, iPod docks, and free Wi-Fi.

Hilton Garden Inn Times Square

3.

Hilton Garden Inn Times Square Rating: 3.0 Pearls

Categories: Business, Kid-Friendly

Renovated in 2008, this 369-room Hilton comes with some snazzy features, especially for the price: a top-notch gym; free printing from the business center; free Wi-Fi throughout the hotel; and large rooms with superb beds. It's a great value, even if it is just outside the heart of Times Square.

Hotel Mela

4.

Hotel Mela Rating: 3.5 Pearls

Categories: Boutique, Business, Romantic

In the heart of Times Square but just outside most of the noise, the 228-room Mela boutique brings a little South Beach style to Manhattan. Free Wi-Fi, great beds, and a high-quality fitness center make the Mela an excellent alternative to the Marriott Marquis or Westin Times Square.

Casablanca Hotel

5.

Casablanca Hotel Rating: 3.5 Pearls

Categories: Boutique

A homey boutique in the heart of Times Square, the Casablanca is a small treasure among massive hotels. A daily wine and cheese reception and free breakfast in the cozy lounge add to its charm. Rooms are nothing special, but overall, the Casablanca is a great pick for the price.

The Time

6.

The Time Rating: 3.5 Pearls

Categories: Boutique

Clean rooms, an excellent, uncommonly quiet Times Square location, and a happening lounge -- for the price, the Time is a fine option. The clean, bright guest rooms come with flat-screen TVs, iPod-compatible Bose radios, and terry cloth robes.

Room Mate Grace

7.

Room Mate Grace Rating: 3.5 Pearls

Categories: Boutique

For the price, this colorful 139-room Times Square boutique hotel offers more: great beds; free Wi-Fi; free healthy breakfasts; sauna, steam room, gym; great rates on four-person rooms; and a small indoor lobby pool and swim-up bar that hosts a popular gay pool party every Wednesday.

View all Times Square Hotels

Oyster Recommends

Explore More Times Square Hotels

Browse Hotel Slideshows

Loading Live Rates
Loading...