View All Hotels in Gramercy and Murray Hill

Hotel 17 2.0

Gramercy and Murray Hill, Manhattan, New York City

Review Summary

Photos and Review by


  • Basic accommodations for travelers on a budget
  • Hands-down, the lowest price for the most space in the area
  • Blocks from Gramercy Park and Union Square
  • Free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs and work desks in rooms
  • Toiletries and towels for shared bathrooms; most rooms have sinks
  • Larger rooms have coffeemakers
  • Charming neighborhood views from some rooms


  • Decor and furnishings are very dated
  • Patterned bedspreads may turn off modern travelers
  • Shared bathrooms only
  • No lobby or dining options (though not expected in this price range)

Bottom Line

The budget-friendly, 150-room Hotel 17 in the residential Gramercy neighborhood is even cheaper than its smaller sister property in Midtown, Hotel 31. But there are no private room and bathroom options here and the location is a bit less central. Rooms of varying sizes (larger rooms include coffeemakers and sinks) have clean but outdated decor -- think patterned bedspreads and mini-blinds. But prices are consistently among the cheapest in this posh neighborhood. One reason for this is shared bathrooms -- each floor has four bathrooms (two bathrooms for every seven rooms); there's rarely a wait and the hard-working cleaning crew keeps the place spic and span.

Oyster Awards

Oyster Hotel Photos

View All 8 Albums

Oyster Hotel Review


Not much else besides a place to drop the bags

Clean bathrooms are shared, but there is rarely a wait

A few guests can occasionally be found making use of the outdoor smoking area, but otherwise, it's easy to feel like the only person staying here. The lobby consists of a small front desk area for check-in, but guests don't spend time here. Though bathrooms are shared, there is rarely a wait. The low-key scene is safe and quiet; this is no more than a place to drop the bags and rest.


A posh, quiet residential area

Map of Hotel 17

Hotel 17 gets its name for its location: 17th Street, or East 17th to be precise. While Hotel 31 is better suited for those who require close proximity to Midtown, this slightly more downtown location would be more appropriate for those who want to be closer to the Union Square area and its many bars, restaurants, and shops. The L Train to Williamsburg, Brooklyn -- one of the trendiest neighborhoods in the city for dining and drinking -- is just two blocks away.


Basic accommodations are clean, but have outdated bedspreads

The Double Room with Shared Bath is clean, but has outdated bedspread and well-worn furnishings

Though the building doesn't seem big, it surprisingly houses 150 rooms, which come with two double beds, one full bed, one queen bed, two twin beds or a mixture of the above. Well-worn furnishings, wallpapers and bedspreads are dated, and to some, ugly; travelers who are used to white duvet covers may have a hard time adjusting. There are two full (and clean) shared bathrooms for every seven rooms, and a wait is rare.


Not much besides free Wi-Fi

There is little else onsite besides a front desk area, where long-standing staff can offer neighborhood advice

Besides offering free Wi-Fi, early check-ins, baggage storage and neighborhood advice from the long-standing staff (many have worked here for over 18 years) the hotel lacks property features. Food, drink and even seating areas are nil! This is a place to bathe, change and sleep.

Customers Who Viewed Hotel 17 Also Viewed

Things You Should Know About Hotel 17


225 East 17th Street, New York City, New York 10003, United States

Have You Liked Us Yet? We Love to be Liked