Milford Plaza — User Comments Rating: 2.5 Pearls

Times Square, Manhattan, New York City

I just stayed at the Milford this past Monday 11/28/11. It was my first time since 1989. They have renovated nearly all the rooms and they are really nice. I booked a renovated one. The bathrooms were small but with modern fixtures and a nice shower head. The total cost for room tax and all wa $112. It was a block away from Times Square. THe staff were very helpful and accomodating, the doormen were very approachable and downright nice! My only complaint was the air conditioner (although new) did not work so well,but the weather was so nice that we had the windows open and the ice machines did not work on our floor... I am sure the reason is the ongoing construction. I would definitely recommend this hotel especially if you want to stay in that area of the city! Not as fancy as the Kimpton chain which is my favorite but for 1/5 of the price it is a definite option!

Cauchemar

By chantale boileau from MOntréal on Sep 6, 2011

Cet hôtel est un des pires que j'ai jamais vus dans ma vie. Et je voyage depuis 30 ans dans toutes sortes de pays. La salle de bain est couverte de moisissure, l'odeur se répand partout, les draps sont déchirés, le tapis est archi sale, il faisait froid et aucune couverture supplémentaire. J'ai voulu repasser un pantalon, mais en saisissant la planche à repasser, une espèce de liguide brun gommant a coulé sur ma main. LE PIRE, c'est que la nuit, quelqu'un a essayé d'entrer dans ma chambre (1439). Heureusement que j'avais mis la chaîne de sécurité. Le personnel est aberrant tellement il est antipathique… Cet hôtel est une honte pour New York et ne mérite pas de porter ce nom… C'est un trou.

This hotel is one of the worst I have ever seen in my life. And I've travel for 30 years in a variety of countries. The bathroom is covered with mold, the smell is spreading everywhere, the sheets are torn, the carpet was really dirty, it was cold and no additional blankets. I tried ironing pants, but when I grabbed the ironing board, a kind of liquid brown gum got on my hand. The worst part was the night; someone tried to enter my room (1439). Luckily I had put the security chain on. The staff is so absurd that it is repugnant ... The hotel is a disgrace to New York and does not deserve to wear that name ... It's a hole.

Lovely Hotel

By laura barbosa from Nevada on Apr 18, 2011

The standard room was a bit small, but expected in New York. The room was nicely decorated, clean and comfortable. The staff was excellent, very friendly and helpful. The breakfast buffet and cheese and wine in the evening was excellent and very welcome.