The Gotham Hotel Rating: 4.0 Pearls
Midtown East, Manhattan, New York City

Oyster Review Summary

Photos and Review by Oyster.com Investigators

Pros

  • Modern boutique hotel with a cool, bookish vibe
  • Midtown location steps from Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center
  • Free glass of chardonnay or pinot noir upon arrival
  • Tenpenny is a cozy restaurant and bar
  • All rooms have balconies or terraces
  • iPod docks, flat-screen TVs, minibars, and coffeemakers
  • Plush bathrobes and toiletries by C.O. Bigelow
  • Turndown service with fresh fruit
  • 2 communal terraces with city views for drinks or private dinners
  • Business center, free Wi-Fi, and use of a nearby sports club

Cons

  • No pool or Jacuzzi
  • Some balconies are tiny
  • Beds have sharp corners
  • Valet parking comes with a hefty fee

Bottom Line

The Gotham, one of Manhattan’s skinniest hotels, opened its doors in 2009 in the same spot that was once endearingly known as the Gotham Book Mart. The 66-room boutique pays homage to its former tenant through the name, of course, but also through the sophisticated bookish decor. The cheerful lobby has a welcoming feel -- even more so when guests are offered a glass of wine from one of the trendily dressed staff members (no uniforms here). With the cozy Tenpenny restaurant and bar in the rear, Gotham attracts regular corporate types for the ultra-cool, modern rooms. Every room comes with a balcony or patio, and guests enjoy free Wi-Fi and use of the neighborhood sports club.

Categories

, , ,

Oyster Hotel Photos

View All 8 Albums

Customers Who Viewed The Gotham Hotel Also Viewed

Royalton
15% viewed
Royalton
Midtown West, Manhattan
The London NYC
15% viewed
The London NYC
Midtown West, Manhattan
The Refinery Hotel
15% viewed
The Refinery Hotel
Midtown West, Manhattan
The James New York
15% viewed
The James New York
SoHo, Manhattan

Oyster Hotel Review

 Scene

A modern boutique hotel that pays homage to its bookstore roots

Lobby of the Gotham Hotel
Lobby of the Gotham Hotel

For newcomers, this narrow Midtown hotel is easy to miss: There is no formal check-in desk, and the doorman seems out of place. Is this someone’s home or an art gallery? No, it’s a modern boutique hotel in a former bookstore. Upon arrival guests are offered a glass of wine while they continue with a paperless check-in process. Arriving to New York City can be a stressful process, after all, and the team at Gotham places a lot of importance on making guests feel comfortable. The rest of the main floor consists of nothing more than a set of elevators, business center, and a restaurant/lounge in the rear. The simple layout makes the most of the limited space -- it’s chic, and oh-so New York.

 Location

An ideal Midtown location near Fifth Avenue and top tourist sites

The Gotham Hotel has a central Midtown location close to corporate headquarters and flagship stores. Located on 46th Street, the bookish vibe provides a respite from the hustle and bustle of nearby sightseeing. NBC Studios, Rockefeller Center, the New York Public Library, and Bryant Park are within walking distance. Other area attractions include Saks Fifth Avenue, St. Patrick’s Cathedral, and Radio City Music Hall. For caffeine addicts, a cafe next door serves espresso drinks and pastries.

  • 20-minute drive to LaGuardia Airport
  • 30-minute drive to JFK International Airport
  • One block from Fifth Avenue for shopping
  • 6-minute walk to Rockefeller Center and NBC Studios
  • 7-minute walk to Grand Central Station
  • 9-minute walk to Times Square and the Theater District
  • 10-minute walk to the B, D, F, M subway lines
  • 10-minute walk to the Museum of Modern Art
  • 11 minutes by subway or 21-minute walk to Columbus Circle
  • 14-minute walk to Central Park
  • 15 minutes by subway to the American Museum of Natural History
  • 15 minutes by subway to Penn Station
  • 21 minutes by bus to the Metropolitan Museum of Art
  • 24 minutes by subway to Battery Park, where the ferry terminal to visit the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island is located
  • 27 minutes by subway to South Street Seaport, a waterfront shop and restaurant hub in the Financial District

 Rooms

Modern, minimalistic rooms have smart European touches

Balcony from the Gotham Two Room
Balcony from the Gotham Two Room

The Gotham Hotel is one of the skinniest hotels in Manhattan. There are only two to four rooms per floor, so the chances of running into other guests while waiting for the elevators are slim. All rooms come with private balconies or terraces, and two of the floors have larger communal terraces that can be reserved for drinks and/or private dinners.

  • 400 thread count linens and plush terrycloth bathrobes
  • Balconies or terraces
  • iPod docks, and flat-screen TVs with multi-media connectivity
  • Minibars and a selection of top-shelf liquors
  • Work desks and ergonomic chairs
  • Books stationed in each room to fit with the literary theme
  • Toiletries by C.O. Bigelow
  • Coffeemakers with free coffee and tea
  • Turndown service with fresh fruit
  • Central air and heat
  • Free Wi-Fi

 Features

Free wine upon arrival and free access to a neighborhood sports club

19th floor terrace with view of city
19th floor terrace with view of city
  • A comfortable lobby with free wine upon arrival
  • Paperless check-in process
  • Business center with printer use
  • Free access to a neighborhood sports center
  • In-room spa treatments available
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Books placed around the hotel and rooms, purchased from Housing Works, a non-profit organization
  • Two terraces with city views for drinks and/or private dinners
  • Pet-friendly hotel with dog walking available
  • Same-day laundry and dry-cleaning service
  • Valet parking, though fees are high
  • View Full List of Amenities

 Food

Tenpenny restaurant and bar provides New American food in a cozy setting

The dining room and bar of Tenpenny
The dining room and bar of Tenpenny

It’s impossible to miss the wooden doors leading to the atmospheric restaurant and lounge on the main floor of the hotel. Tenpenny is windowless, save for a rare skylight in the rear, and decor includes brick walls, reclaimed-wood floors, walnut tables, and rustic lamps. The stone bar can seat up to 12 for cocktails, and menu items include artisanal cheeses, oysters, pasta dishes, and New American additions such as pork belly croquettes and ocean trout crudo.

 Bottom Line

The Gotham, one of Manhattan’s skinniest hotels, opened its doors in 2009 in the same spot that was once endearingly known as the Gotham Book Mart. The 66-room boutique pays homage to its former tenant through the name, of course, but also through the sophisticated bookish decor. The cheerful lobby has a welcoming feel -- even more so when guests are offered a glass of wine from one of the trendily dressed staff members (no uniforms here). With the cozy Tenpenny restaurant and bar in the rear, Gotham attracts regular corporate types for the ultra-cool, modern rooms. Every room comes with a balcony or patio, and guests enjoy free Wi-Fi and use of the neighborhood sports club.

Things You Should Know About The Gotham Hotel

Address

  • 16 E. 46th St, New York, NY 10017

Room Types

  • One Room
  • Skyline Room
  • Three Room
  • Two Room

Find the Lowest Price - Enter Dates

Check-in
Check-out
Guests
Compare rates on dozens of sites
 AVG/NIGHT 
Hotels.com  
Expedia.com  
Tingo.com  
Booking.com  
Travelocity  
Otel.com  
Priceline.com  
CheapTickets.com  

All About Oyster

You Can't Return a Bad Vacation.

Our special investigators visit, photograph, review and rate each hotel. We uncover the truth, before it's "uh-oh" time.

Go undercover with an Oyster Investigator The Today Show
Go Undercover with an Oyster Investigator
See 70 Videos of Oyster on TV

Nearby Hotels to Consider

The Roosevelt Hotel
Holiday Inn Express New York City Fifth Avenue
Mansfield Hotel
  • Mansfield Hotel
  • Midtown West, Manhattan
  • Rating: 35 Pearls
  • Distance: 0.2 mi
The Hotel at Times Square

Hotel Features

Number of Rooms: 66
Internet Access: Yes
Pets Allowed: Yes
Cribs: Yes
View All

Hotel Information

Location: Midtown East, Manhattan
Address: 16 E. 46th St, New York, NY 10017
(See Map)
Loading Live Rates
Loading...