Nantucket Hotels › Historic Hotels
4 Hotels Found
Sort by:
The White Elephant Hotel

The White Elephant Hotel Rating: 4.5 Pearls

THIS HOTEL HAS UNDERGONE MAJOR RENOVATIONS SINCE OUR VISIT. WE WILL UPDATE OUR REVIEW AND PHOTOS AS SOON AS WE CAN. White Elephant Hotel has a prime location, on the water and walkable to downtown. But to get a gorgeous view, be prepared to pay high prices -- which some guests say are too high since the rooms/cottages themselves aren't up to par. A spa and a fine dining restaurant give this luxury inn a boost -- but keep in mind there is no pool. Bottom line here is, if you have the money to spend for the waterfront location, this could be a good choice for you. But don't expect luxury in the rooms themselves.
Union Street Inn

Union Street Inn Rating: 4.0 Pearls

This charming, elegant B&B fits in nicely with the Nantucket atmosphere, and is the only inn on the island to provide a full, hot breakfast (thanks to its commercial kitchen). The rooms don’t come cheap, but then again, nothing on Nantucket does. And the fact that downtown is a mere three-minute walk may make it worth the price for some.
The Vanessa Noel Hotel

The Vanessa Noel Hotel Rating: 4.0 Pearls

The Vanessa Noel's eight chic, minimalist rooms feel more New York City than Nantucket -- and as in New York City, some rooms and bathrooms are small (it's a historic building, though, so that is to be expected). The only common area for guests being the colorful Cafe V Bar, adjacent to the lobby, where breakfast is served daily in the high season. The location in a quiet residential neighborhood a couple blocks from downtown is quite convenient for guests wanting to explore the Nantucket scene.
Centerboard Inn

Centerboard Inn Rating: 3.0 Pearls

THIS HOTEL HAS BEEN RENOVATED SINCE OUR VISIT. WE WILL UPDATE OUR PHOTOS AS SOON AS WE CAN. For an authentic New England inn experience, the Centerboard Inn is a great choice -- offering up an historic Nantucket home close to all the shopping and dining of the downtown area, as well as a short walk to the Children's Beach. The inn features charming rooms, each with its own decor and feel, and an innkeeper that creates a true bed-and-breakfast-style stay. The entire property was renovated from head to toe in 2012, introducing brighter interiors with modern beach-chic decor. But some rooms and bathrooms are a bit tight on space.

Are we missing a hotel you love? We are busy adding more hotels to Oyster every day. In fact, in this year alone we have added over 2,000 new hotels.

Because we visit each hotel personally, it's not an overnight process - but the results are worth it.

Email us your favorite hotels, and we will visit them ASAP.


Oyster Pearl Rating

  • Award-Winning

What's Your Style?

  • Historic
  • Kid-Friendly
  • Luxury
  • Romantic
  • Boutique
  • Resort


  • Air Conditioner
  • Basic Television
  • Business Center
  • Cable Television
  • Cribs
› See More...
Loading Live Rates