9 Underrated Beach Destinations

See recent posts by Jane Reynolds

Some destinations always come to mind when people think of beach getaways: Waikiki Beach in Hawaii, Miami's South Beach, and the crowded sands in Cancun. Some spots, however, are often overlooked and it makes them that much better. Fewer people, untouched nature, you name it; underrated beach destinations are hidden gems that can be just what you're looking for. Check out our list of nine underrated beach destinations -- and make a trip before the secret is out!

1. Vieques Island, Puerto Rico

Vieques Island is surrounded by gorgeous, clear waters.

This unique little island offers travelers pure, undeveloped land, mainly thanks to the US Navy’s former use of a good portion of the island. The Navy left in 2003, however, and the land it once occupied is now a national wildlife refuge. Tourists to Puerto Rico often don’t leave the mainland as it takes an extra puddle-jumper to get to Vieques and there are few tourist attractions. Instead, attractions are nature-oriented: The island’s stunning, untouched white-sand beaches and famous bioluminescent bay are the highlights, but it also features walking trails, 300-year-old trees, and some of the top snorkeling spots in the country.

Where to Stay: The quaint Inn on the Blue Horizon is a smaller, more affordable option compared to the nearby W Vieques. The inn features phenomenal ocean views, pretty Mediterranean-style architecture, and wild horses roaming the grounds.

2. Jacksonville Beach, Florida

Skip the crowds by heading to Jacksonville Beach.

Jacksonville Beach is often overlooked for its Florida beach destination counterparts, but the area offers several nice beaches, andis home to world-renowned golf courses and a lively arts scene. The beach scene in Jacksonville is a bit limited by the weather; though the city experiences mild winters, the waters are too cold for beachgoers from November to March. But the upside is that, during the beach season, the sands are less crowded than southern Florida beaches, and are still great spots for surfing, swimming, and fishing. Plus, rates and restaurants are often less expensive than those elsewhere in the state.

Where to Stay: The Mediterranean-inspired Lodge & Club at Ponte Vedra Beach occupies a quiet, uncrowded beachfront. There are beautiful ocean views from balconies and romantic window seats in each of the hotel’s 66 rooms.

3. Montauk, New York

Montauk is yet another underrated beach on the midst of discovery, so make a trip before the crowds come for good.

Though Montauk is technically in the Hamptons, there are a lot of things that set this small town apart from other “quintessential Hamptons” destinations and makes it more of a hidden gem than the others. First off, there’s the location: Montauk, nicknamed “The End,” is literally on the end of Long Island — the easternmost tip, surrounded on three sides by water, and 12 miles from the next Hamptons town. It’s laid-back feel attracts more surfers and fishermen than socialites. Long-time lovers of Montauk worry about the area’s growing popularity and new hipster vibe; recent “Save Montauk” signs and shirts have even taken notice of The New York Times. But a lack of chain restaurants and shops helps to preserve the small-town feel. Only time will tell if Montauk is the next underrated beach destination to be, well, “rated” we guess.

Where to Stay: If you’re looking for an “old Montauk” scene, skip the more-hipster-with-every-day Sole East and stay at the Panoramic View. The 10-acre site is situated on a hillside and includes pretty walkways, an outdoor pool, state-of-the-art fitness center, and private beach access.

4. Lanai, Hawaii

Soft sand, quiet beaches, glamorous (but understated) people; Lanai is certainly Hawaii’s hidden gem.

Like Vieques Island, Lanai is a bit difficult to get to (most visitors take a ferry from Maui) which helps keep the island uncrowded, despite its growing popularity as a luxe getaway. But with not a single stoplight on the island, it really doesn’t need to be said that this island is a bit off of Hawaii’s beaten path. Even though its jaw-dropping natural beauty (which includes cerulean ocean and lush forests) is its best asset, small-town coziness accompanies this undeveloped isle. Lanai also offers some of the typical resort destination activities, but with a distinct Lanai twist. For instance, the Challenge at Manele in Lanai City is your basic 18-hole golf course, but it spreads out over fields of lava pressing up against scenic coastal cliffs.

Where to Stay: Though the Four Seasons Lodge at Koele is also extremely luxurious, it’s sister Four Seasons at Manele Bay trumps it with it’s beachfront location. It also offers top-rated dining, a Jack Nicklaus-designed golf course, and a pristine pool and spa.

5. San Juan Islands, Washington

The San Juan Islands are home to serene lake beaches.

The San Juan Islands are a popular summer getaway for Washingtonians, but otherwise are relatively quiet, unknown spots. With a relaxed, back-to-nature vibe, the islands are home to farmlands, evergreen forests, nature trails, whale-watching, and mom-and-pop shops. Temperatures are moderate, and rainfall is about half that of Seattle’s, so it’s possible to spend plenty of time outdoors. Popular activities include hiking, wildlife spotting, sailing, swimming, and kayaking and no destination on the islands ever feels overcrowded.

Where to Stay: It’s hard to beat Lakedale Resort, an 82-acre property in quiet Friday Harbor. With a lakefront location, the resort offers everything from an airstream trailer to canvas cabins so guests can choose how luxe or rugged they make their vacation.

6. York, Maine

York has that posh-meets-understated vibe that Maine is known for.

This quaint town along Maine’s coast is notable for its history, beaches, and outdoor activities. The 18th-century former jailhouse remains, as do historic homes and the Nubble Lighthouse — one of the most photographed lighthouses in the country. York experiences a surge of visitors during the summertime, but it rarely reaches a point of being overwhelming like so many other beach destinations. Tourists flock to the coast, lined by sandy and rocky beaches, and enjoy activities such as swimming, surfing, kayaking, fishing, and even whale-watching. Those looking for the area’s most secluded beaches may consider heading to York’s Cape Neddick, a quiet little beach with views of the lighthouse.

Where to Stay: Stage Neck Innhas a scenic oceanfront location, right next to York Harbor Beach. The 58-room hotel offers some outstanding features, such as an outdoor freshwater pool with ocean views, an indoor atrium pool, and a fire pit surrounded by Adirondack chairs.

7. Bal Harbour, Florida

Bal Harbour has the best of both worlds, with a location that’s close enough to Miami’s more popular spots but far enough from Miami’s crowds.

The beach at Bal Harbour is the one above; South Beach looks like this. While most tourists to Miami flocks to SoBe, the ones in the know head to Bal Harbour. Known for its prime shopping at the Bal Harbour Shops, Bal Harbour is a posh Miami suburb. The pier down on the inlet is a nice place to people- (and bird-) watch. The locals fish out on the rocks; the pelicans take a more direct approach.

Where to Stay: Though not as luxe as the nearby St. Regis and ONE, the Sea View Hotelis an affordable option just across the street from the shops. Rooms are simple, but the lobby is gorgeous and the hotel features an Olympic-size pool.

8. Lake Tahoe, California

Trade in your snow skis for water skis when heading to Lake Tahoe this summer.

Nestled in the Sierra Nevada mountains, Lake Tahoe is known as a premiere ski destination and attracts plenty of visitors heading for the slopes. In the summer, a smaller — but equally outdoorsy — crowd comes for the hiking, fishing, swimming, and kayaking, all centered around the pristine lake. There are also a few dispersed museums and historic mansions, and hot-air ballooning and gondola rides are popular ways of taking in the views.

Where to Stay: Sitting in a small forest area across the street from Lake Tahoe, the Cedar Glen Lodge is a throwback to a simpler time with its motor-lodge design and woodsy cabins. Despite its 1930s-era vintage, the hotel is in a state of constant renewal. Friendly owners, lake access, a heated outdoor pool charming lodge-style rooms, and free continental breakfast all make the Cedar Glen a great value.

9. Long Beach, New York

Long Beach is recovering post-Sandy.

A lively beach destination during the 1920s and 30s, Long Beach became a rundown and forgotten spot during the 1940s when airfare became cheaper and years of corruption sullied the town’s reputation. In the last several decades, however, the city has undergone promising urban renewal, and though Hurricane Sandy hit the area hard — wiping away the iconic boardwalk — city planners are working hard to get things back up and running as soon as possible. Once the beach re-opens (fingers crossed it’s in time for beach weather this year!), Long Beach will once again be a great pick for a quieter, and cheaper, alternative to the Hamptons or Atlantic City’s beaches. Plus, the Long Island Railroad, as well as several bus lines, make it easy to get to the beach from numerous areas of New York.

Where to Stay: The Allegria Hotel is a chic 143-room boutique delivering a dose of Miami style right on the Long Beach boardwalk. Big rooms have light, airy decor, plush beds, and sleek limestone bathrooms; some have beach and ocean views. The restaurants serve gourmet organic cuisine and tasty cocktails, and in nice weather Atlantica restaurant opens its windows right up to the boardwalk.


All products are independently selected by our writers and editors. If you buy something through our links, Oyster may earn an affiliate commission.