Centrally located near plenty of recreation and dining options
Private shoreline on Eagle Harbor
Adjacent to the Old Post Office restaurant and outdoor fire pit
Some rooms have views of the bay
Suites with full kitchens available
Outdoor pool and hot tub
Fitness room with a sauna
Free Wi-Fi throughout
Breakfast not included
Some rooms are small
In a dry (alcohol-free) area (pro for some)
The Edgewater Resort is a mid-range hotel across the street from its own private stretch of shoreline in downtown Ephraim. Many of its rooms overlook the bay and the hotel also offers suites with full kitchens and private cottages tucked away in the backyard. On weekends, the adjacent Old Post Office restaurant makes use of a communal fire pit for its notorious fish boils, a Door County tradition steeped in Scandinavian ancestry and generous amounts of kerosene. The hotel is particularly suited for couples and families who plan on experiencing the unique outdoor dinner. It's also worth checking the nearby The Eagle Harbor Inn, which has some similar amenities, along with free breakfast.
Built in 1900, the Edgewater Resort is the kind of classic Door County property that looks like it could have been plucked right out of New England. Its white facade and long verandas face the bay across manicured lawns. The quaint lobby has a small front desk, with the usual multitude of brochures and Door County dining guides covering most available surfaces. Painted wood and blue wicker furniture sit around a stone fireplace, adorned with a wooden sailboat. Most guests are vacationing families and couples.
Across the street from the bay, central to dining and attractions
Right across the street from its own private waterfront, the Edgewater Resort is centrally located in Ephraim next to the Old Post Office restaurant. Other Ephraim restaurants are within walking distance, but guests should note that there are no bars here, as the property is located in the state's last dry municipality. For watering holes and additional dining options, guests can head to neighboring Sister Bay or Fish Creek, a few minutes’ drive away. The Northern Sky Theater is a three-minute drive and Peninsula State Park, which includes a golf course, is about a 10-minute drive, while Potawatomi State Park is close to an hour away. Austin Straubel International Airport in Green Bay is a 90-minute drive, and General Mitchell International Airport in Milwaukee is a little more than a three-hour drive from the hotel.
The resort has 30 rooms and cottages, with the latter in standalone buildings behind the main hotel. Rooms have a bright contemporary decor with wood furniture and wicker armchairs. Rooms on the first and second floor share the communal verandas, while third-floor suites have their own private balconies overlooking the bay. The Traditional Rooms are on the small side, but microwaves, mini-fridges, and coffeemakers come standard, as do flat-screen TVs. Pastel bathrooms have shower/tub combos. Suites add in-room whirlpool tubs, gas fireplaces, and full kitchens with ovens and breakfast bars. Cottages range from simple studios to one- or two-bedroom options. The larger cottages have gas fireplaces, and kitchenettes, or full kitchens. Pets are welcome in the cottages, for a fee.
Outdoor pool and hot tub, private shoreline, communal fire pit
The resort has its own private shoreline, and guests can watch the sun set over the bay from its park benches or manicured lawns. Across the road, the main building straddles an outdoor pool and hot tub and there's a sun deck with umbrellas and lounge chairs. Around back, a wide circle of rustic benches surround a fire pit on the where people gather for s'mores, or the adjacent restaurant's famous fish boils (and cherry pies). The hotel also has a simple fitness room and a sauna.