Pros

  • Grand, imposing Victorian Gothic architecture and historic touches throughout
  • Set in heart of historic Oxford opposite the university
  • Regular site of famed British TV series
  • Elegantly ornate, traditional interiors offer nice places to congregate
  • Certain rooms are wheelchair-accessible
  • Sumptuously decorated restaurant and Morse Bar serve tasty cuisine
  • Modern, basement spa features a hot tub and sauna
  • Meeting spaces are available for business travelers
  • Free Wi-Fi (though it can be patchy)
See More Pros

Cons

  • Some rooms a little shabby and dated
  • Decor might feel staid for some tastes
  • Certain features are pricey, including spa entry
  • Fitness center has just a few cardio machines
See More Cons

Bottom Line

It's hard not to be impressed by the 19th-century Gothic architecture of this upscale landmark hotel. Its sumptuous interiors are no less striking, though rooms are lacking the polish you'd expect from a property of this caliber. The location couldn't be better for exploring Oxford center, and Inspector Morse fans will recognize the decor from frequent shoots at the hotel. Overall, it might be a little old-fashioned for some, and rooms aren't fully worth the price, but the building and its setting are certainly quite special.

See More Bottom Line

Amenities

  • Fitness Center
  • Internet
  • Jacuzzi
  • Pets Allowed
  • Spa

Oyster Hotel Review

Macdonald Randolph Hotel

Scene

Imposing Victorian Gothic hotel awash with traditional period detailing

Built in 1864 by Oxford architect William Wilkinson, the Macdonald Randolph is a fine example of 19th-century Victorian Gothic Revivalism, with its imposing facade of lancet windows and ornate eaves with a wrought-iron portico. Inside, the lobby is no less striking -- period detailing from Corinthian columns, elegantly vaulted ceilings, and stained glass windows all blend to create an impressive scene of traditional Victorian refinement. Keep in mind, however, that parts of the property can certainly feel a little stiff and old-fashioned if a more formal decor isn’t your thing. Consequently, clientele tend toward those with more traditional tastes, as well as fans of the Inspector Morse detective TV show in which the hotel has been featured heavily.

See More Scene

Location

Set in Oxford's historic heart opposite the renowned university

The hotel is located on a busy street corner right in the heart of the historic city of Oxford, across the street from the famous Oxford University and Ashmolean Museum of Art and Archaeology. It's also just a 10-minute walk (half a mile) from Oxford train station. Heathrow Airport is about 48 miles southeast, or almost an hour away driving, while getting to London takes more than an hour by train or car.

See More Location

Rooms

Individually-styled rooms lack five-star pizzazz

The Macdonald Randolph's 151 rooms range in categories from standard units to suites. They are individually decorated but all in a strictly traditional fashion, with patterned fabrics, neutral tones, and antique-style furnishings. Decor lacks the flair you'd expect from a hotel that bills itself as five-star, and some rooms feel a little dated. In-room amenities, too, are all there, but lack real high-end quality. Bathrooms, however, are generally finished in a smart, homey style, with shower/tub combos, heated towel railings, and Molton Brown toiletries.

See More Rooms

Features

Sumptuously traditional dining and a contemporary basement spa

The Restaurant at the Randolph offers fine dining in a baronial hall-style room with large windows overlooking Beaumont Street and the Ashmolean Museum. Named after the fictional detective, the Morse Bar is also sumptuously decorated and was featured regularly in the long-running TV show. The basement spa is well-designed and modern, offering a range of treatments as well as a hot tub, sauna, and sensation shower. Keep in mind there’s a charge for entry, and it isn’t cheap. Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property and on-site parking is also offered, though it's pricey as well.

See More Features

Oyster Hotel Review

Macdonald Randolph Hotel

Scene

Imposing Victorian Gothic hotel awash with traditional period detailing

Built in 1864 by Oxford architect William Wilkinson, the Macdonald Randolph is a fine example of 19th-century Victorian Gothic Revivalism, with its imposing facade of lancet windows and ornate eaves with a wrought-iron portico. Inside, the lobby is no less striking -- period detailing from Corinthian columns, elegantly vaulted ceilings, and stained glass windows all blend to create an impressive scene of traditional Victorian refinement. Keep in mind, however, that parts of the property can certainly feel a little stiff and old-fashioned if a more formal decor isn’t your thing. Consequently, clientele tend toward those with more traditional tastes, as well as fans of the Inspector Morse detective TV show in which the hotel has been featured heavily.

See More Scene

Location

Set in Oxford's historic heart opposite the renowned university

The hotel is located on a busy street corner right in the heart of the historic city of Oxford, across the street from the famous Oxford University and Ashmolean Museum of Art and Archaeology. It's also just a 10-minute walk (half a mile) from Oxford train station. Heathrow Airport is about 48 miles southeast, or almost an hour away driving, while getting to London takes more than an hour by train or car.

See More Location

Rooms

Individually-styled rooms lack five-star pizzazz

The Macdonald Randolph's 151 rooms range in categories from standard units to suites. They are individually decorated but all in a strictly traditional fashion, with patterned fabrics, neutral tones, and antique-style furnishings. Decor lacks the flair you'd expect from a hotel that bills itself as five-star, and some rooms feel a little dated. In-room amenities, too, are all there, but lack real high-end quality. Bathrooms, however, are generally finished in a smart, homey style, with shower/tub combos, heated towel railings, and Molton Brown toiletries.

See More Rooms

Features

Sumptuously traditional dining and a contemporary basement spa

The Restaurant at the Randolph offers fine dining in a baronial hall-style room with large windows overlooking Beaumont Street and the Ashmolean Museum. Named after the fictional detective, the Morse Bar is also sumptuously decorated and was featured regularly in the long-running TV show. The basement spa is well-designed and modern, offering a range of treatments as well as a hot tub, sauna, and sensation shower. Keep in mind there’s a charge for entry, and it isn’t cheap. Free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property and on-site parking is also offered, though it's pricey as well.

See More Features

Best Rates

Amenities

  • Air Conditioner

  • Airport Transportation

  • Balcony / Terrace / Patio

  • Business Center

  • Concierge

  • Dry Cleaning

  • Fitness Center

  • Internet

  • Jacuzzi

  • Laundry

  • Meeting / Conference Rooms

  • Mini Bar (with liquor)

  • Pets Allowed

  • Room Service

  • Separate Bedroom / Living Room Space

  • Spa

Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.