Photos and Review by

Review Summary


  • A half-block from Times Square, but quiet and low-key
  • Large rooms with floor-to-ceiling windows and bathrooms with separate shower and tub
  • Free continental breakfast buffet
  • Free evening happy hour, with snacks, wine, and beer
  • Small, free business center, with two computers and a printer
  • Free Wi-Fi


  • Gym is located in the (much busier) neighboring property
  • Breakfast-only restaurant is located in the neighboring property

Bottom Line

This upscale annex of the massive and generic Millennium Broadway hotel next door offers 125 large, quiet, and clean rooms and proximity to Times Square -- but not much else. The Premier provides value with a free breakfast buffet and evening happy hour, but its gym is actually next door, on the 16th floor of the Millennium, though it is open 24 hours a day. All things considered, the Premier's prices are too high for what you get. For a Times Square four-pearler with chicer rooms, look into Row NYC.

Oyster Hotel Photos

See All Albums

Oyster Hotel Review


The supposedly upscale sister property of the adjacent Millennium Broadway

The lobby of this boutique annex of the huge and generic Millennium Broadway is clean and bright, but falls short of luxury standards

The 125-room Premier is supposed to be the luxe, boutique annex of the huge and generic Millennium Broadway, which is next door. But not enough sets it apart from its sibling to justify the luxury price tag. At 425 square feet, the rooms are unusually large, with floor-to-ceiling windows and clean, minimalist design. They're also quiet -- a rarity in densely packed Times Square. The hotel offers free breakfast and evening hors d'oeuvres, but it falls short of true luxury standards.


Around the corner from Times Square, but not so close that guests will be kept awake by the lights or traffic.

Map of The Premier

Located on relatively quiet 44th Street, between Broadway and Sixth Avenue, the Premier is half a block away from the heart of Times Square. It's close, but not so close that guests can't get a decent night's rest. There are a handful of hotels on this block, including Hotel Mela, a boutique property.

The block actually feels like transitional corridor between tourist-focused Times Square and business-oriented Midtown West. At the Broadway end of the block, you'll find the flashing lights of the multilevel Virgil's BBQ; at the opposite end, on Sixth Avenue, are the sedate offices of the Wall Street Journal.

More subway lines converge in this area than anywhere else in the city, all of them no more than two blocks away from the hotel. The B, D, F, and M lines are at 42nd Street-Bryant Park, while the 1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, and R lines are at Times Square-42nd Street.

Valet parking is available, and a public garage is directly across the street. For discounted parking rates, guests must park two long blocks west, on 8th Avenue, at the hotel's partner lot.

View the Full Times Square Area Guide

Nearby Hotels



Large, clean rooms with floor-to-ceiling windows

The Standard Queen is spacious by New York standards, and includes floor-to-ceiling windows that allow for plenty of natural light

At 425 square feet, the standard rooms at this hotel are very large for New York City, especially for Times Square. They also have floor-to-ceiling windows, so are especially bright during the day. A subdued color scheme of off-white and pale gray is lightened with blonde-wood furnishings (bed frames, wall panels, side tables, work desks). Dark blue velvet sectional couches with red and printed throw pillows stray from the otherwise predominately beige-based theme.

Rooms have flat-screen TVs with premium cable, safes, iHome docks, and Cuisinart coffeemakers.

Bathrooms are impressively sized, and come with ample counter space, robes, and separate tubs and showers.

Cribs and rollaways are available for a fee, but there are no adjoining rooms.

Rooms and Rates


Fitness center is next door at the Millennium Broadway

The fitness center, located next door at Millennium Broadway, provides a nice range of modern equipment and free weights

The hotel doesn't have its own fitness center, so Premier guests have to use the gym at the Millennium Broadway next door. At least that 24-hour fitness center is big and clean, with a respectable amount of modern equipment, including nearly a dozen cardio machines with TV screens and views of midtown skyscrapers, a variety of strength machines, and a full set of shiny free weights. In-room spa services can be arranged through the concierge.

The Premier doesn't have its own restaurant, but it does offer a free continental breakfast buffet with bagels, pastries, hard-boiled eggs, cold cereal and granola, yogurt, fruit, gluten-free bread, juice, and coffee in the morning. (Many guests point out that the breakfast area has extremely limited seating.) Guests can also upgrade to breakfast at Restaurant Charlotte next door for a fee. Restaurant Charlotte is only open for breakfast, but there is also Charlotte Bar and Lounge, which serves a lighter menu during the day, as well as cocktails.

In the evenings, a two-hour-long manager's reception offers free wine, beer, soft drinks, tea, and coffee, and light snacks like crackers, cheese, olives, and sliced meats.

The 24-hour business center is free to use, and includes two computers and a printer.


Key Features
Fitness Center
Hotel Services
Dry Cleaning
Free Breakfast
Room Service
Family Services
Kids Allowed
Things to Do
Business Center
Fitness Center
Gameroom / Arcade
Room Features
Air Conditioner
Separate Bedroom / Living Room Space
133 W 44th St, New York City, New York 10036, United States
Phone (212) 789-7670
Also Known As
  • Premier New York City
Room Types
  • Guest Room
  • Suite