View All Hotels in Montauk

The Montauk Beach House 4.0

Montauk, The Hamptons, Long Island

Enter Dates for Best Prices

Expedia.com
Hotels.com
Booking.com

Review Summary

Photos and Review by

Pros

  • Exclusive boutique atmosphere with playful trendy decor
  • Walking distance to Montauk town center and the beach
  • Rooms with stylish vintage touches like wrought-iron beds and Edison lamps
  • Two outdoor swimming pools and large sundeck
  • Pool parties with live DJ every Saturday night
  • Breakfast included in room rate
  • Poolside bar and grill serving food and drink
  • Free on-site parking
  • Free Wi-Fi throughout the property
  • On-site gift shop, free bicycle rental

Cons

  • Not located on the beach
  • No fitness center or room service
  • No in-room phones, mini-fridges, or minibars
  • Poor soundproofing in guest rooms
  • Boisterous party scene not for everyone

Bottom Line

The Montauk Beach House is a small, four-pearl boutique hotel with 33 rooms, known for its lively party scene. Though it doesn’t have a beachside location, the two outdoor pools are the central hub of the property -- this is where guests congregate not only to swim and sunbathe, but also to mingle and kick up their heels during the Saturday night pool parties featuring a live DJ. The spacious guest rooms have trendy decor with funky vintage touches like wrought-iron beds, claw-foot bathtubs, and Edison lamps. Travelers looking for a peaceful beach holiday and less of a party scene can consider staying at Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa, considered one of the best beachfront locations in the Hamptons.

Oyster Awards

Flights for this trip with Skyscanner.com

Oyster Hotel Photos

View All 10 Albums

Oyster Hotel Review

Scene

Trendy and laidback vibe with a lively party scene

This trendy Montauk hotel has rustic interiors and a laidback vibe

The Montauk Beach House occupies a long, two-story contemporary building with glass balconies and large windows, set in a natural landscape of large bushes of native feather grass. The interiors are rustic in style, with white-washed wide-plank floors, and paneled walls in white and soft gray, with an eclectic mix of rustic and vintage furniture, creating an inviting, relaxed atmosphere. There are lots of cozy indoor and outdoor lounge areas, where guests can relax and mingle. The vibe here is very young and trendy -- it's a place where people come not only to relax but also to party. Though the hotel caters to all age groups, the loud pool parties may not suit everyone; but there is a quiet “Zen Zone” for those looking for calm. Most guests staying here are young couples spending a long weekend away.

Location

Near the center of Montauk, a two-minute walk from the beach

Map of The Montauk Beach House

The Montauk Beach House is a 15-minute walk from the center of Montauk, a town located on the eastern end of the south shore of Long Island. This is a quiet beach town, and in the vicinity of the hotel there are many shops, restaurants, bars, cafes, and a residential area, all of which is easily reachable on foot. The beach is just two blocks away from the hotel, a two-minute walk. Camp Hero State Park is a 10-minute drive away, while Hither Hills State Park is a 12-minute drive. The closest airport is Long Island MacArthur Airport, a 90-minute drive from here.

Rooms

Spacious and bright rooms with trendy decor

The spacious and bright Whitewater Loft 7 incorporates trendy decor—like the reclaimed wood headboard— for a beach house shabby chic look

The guest rooms at The Montauk Beach House are spacious and bright, thanks to the large windows and attached balconies. The trendy decor is beach house shabby chic, with wide-plank wooden floors, high-beamed ceilings, and interesting vintage furnishings, like wrought-iron beds, Edison lamps, clawfoot bathtubs, old-fashioned pedestal sinks, and bronze bathroom fittings. There are four different room styles available: the Moonlight Rooms on the second floor overlooking the swimming pools have walls painted in bold indigo and plum-colored tones, and high ceilings. The Whitewater Lofts are especially bright, with private south-facing balconies, beautiful oak floors, and handcrafted headboards made of reclaimed wood. The Whitewater Garden Rooms have large 200-square-foot outdoor terraces with daybeds, while the Ocean Mist Terrace Rooms are located by the pool and have pleasant outside seating areas enclosed by walls made of strips of mahogany wood. All rooms have air-conditioning, flat-screen TVs (with few channels), bathrooms with showers, and free toiletries. However, there are no minibars or mini-fridges and no in-room phones, and past guests have complained about the lack of adequate storage space in the form of dressers or wardrobes. Also, soundproofing between rooms is poor, and the pool-facing rooms tend to be noisy because of the weekly pool parties. 

Features

Free breakfast, two outdoor pools, poolside bar, and free Wi-Fi

The hotel has two pools on-site, including one with a poolside shop

The most notable features at The Montauk Beach House are its two outdoor swimming pools and the large sun terrace. This is the central hub of the property, and where guests spend most of their time; either swimming and sunbathing by day, or partying by night. There are plenty of comfortable sun loungers and umbrellas, as well as showers. Every Saturday night a pool party is held with a live DJ. The poolside bar and grill, open daily, offers simple meals and sandwiches. Guests are also offered a free continental buffet breakfast, which gets mixed reviews. A small poolside shop sells bathing suits, casual clothing, jewelry, and even surfboards. Guests can use the hotel’s bicycles free of charge, and free Wi-Fi is available throughout the property. 

Customers Who Viewed The Montauk Beach House Also Viewed

Things You Should Know About The Montauk Beach House

Address

55 S Elmwood Ave, Montauk, Long Island 11954-5342, United States

Don't Forget to Like Us On Facebook! We Love to Be Liked.