Photos and Review by Oyster.com Investigators.
On a private island, a 15-minute drive from Marathon Airport
Conch Key Cottages is located on Walker's Island, a private island along the Overseas Highway. The Marathon Airport and Islamorada are a short drive away, but you will have to drive over an hour to get to the attractions of Key West. The emerald waters surrounding the road and the great snorkeling are the main draw here.
The island itself has nothing besides the hotel, so make sure to stock up on everything you need for your stay, or you will find yourself driving up and down the highway, which can have heavy traffic, especially on weekends.
The mid-range, 13-room Conch Keys Cottages is located on a tiny private island a short drive from Marathon and the Keys' airport. Standard rooms are smallish, but villas and cottages are worth the upgrade, with full kitchens as well as sitting and dining areas. There’s a small but beautiful beach (not swimmable at low tide), free kayaks, and a nice outdoor pool (though there's little space for sunbathing). It offers a relaxing and low-key stay, so don’t expect luxury or a ton to do. Still, it’s a great pick for families and groups.