Pros

  • Charming historic property with antique furnishings and warm hosts
  • Old Town location near Duval Street and the Hemingway Home
  • Individually decorated rooms with flat-screen TVs and mini-fridges; some have balconies or patios
  • Outdoor pool with tropical landscaping and lounge chairs
  • Free breakfast with homemade items and mimosas
  • Free daily happy hour with margaritas
  • Concierge assistance with booking trips and tours
  • Bike rentals available
  • Free Wi-Fi throughout
See More Pros

Cons

  • Pool is unheated
  • One night's deposit needed for some reservations
  • Car/street noise can sometimes be heard in rooms
  • No kids under 12 (a pro for some)
See More Cons

Bottom Line

The 10-room Conch House Heritage Inn is an historic, competitively priced retreat in Old Town Key West in walking distance to Duval Street. This charming, mid-range property draws repeat guests with its warm hospitality, free homemade breakfast, daily happy hour, and tropically landscaped outdoor pool area. Guest rooms are individually decorated with antiques, and have mini-fridges and flat-screen TVs; the suite offers a full kitchen. The unheated pool, though, can be a bit chilly for comfort. Note that kids under age 12 aren't allowed. Another option may be The Mermaid & The Alligator Bed & Breakfast, which has a heated pool. 

See More Bottom Line

Oyster Hotel Review

The Conch House Heritage Inn

Scene

Historic property in Old Town with antique furnishings and a sophisticated yet warm ambiance

Built in the 19th century, The Conch House Heritage Inn is operated by direct descendants of original Key West settlers --the great-grandchildren of an island grocer who helped ship provisions to Cuban revolutionists. The hosts' warm hospitality draws repeat guests who are mainly couples, as no children under 12 are allowed. The property comprises two white clapboard siding houses with black shutters, and there's a lovely front porch with rocking chairs where guests can kick back. Palm trees and tropical plants fill the grounds and shade the outdoor pool area, where there are lounge chairs and wooden Adirondack chairs. Interiors are quietly sophisticated with glistening wood floors, antique wood furnishings, richly patterned fabrics, gilt mirrors, colorful paintings, and ceiling fans. Guests check in at the antique wood reception desk, situated in a breezy room with historic photos on the walls and a large woven rug. Throughout the interior spaces are unique chandeliers and fresh flowers, furthering the elegant yet homey vibe. 

See More Scene

Location

Ideally situated just off Duval Street in Old Town Key West

This ideally located inn sits on Truman Avenue in Old Town Key West, just a few minutes' walk from popular Duval Street -- and a block away from popular dessert restaurant, Better Than Sex. Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum is a five-minute walk, and Mallory Square is a 20-minute walk. Guests will find a CVS, shops, restaurants, bars, and other inns lining the immediate streets. Key West International Airport is a 10-minute drive.

See More Location

Rooms

Comfy rooms with antiques and flat-screen TVs; some have balconies or porches

Rooms are in the main house, poolside cottage, or poolside cabana. All are individually decorated with wood antique furnishings. One room has an island feel, with wicker chairs and brightly colored oil paintings, while another is classic and more traditional, with a wood four-poster bed, crystal chandelier, and marble end tables. Each is air-conditioned and has a mini-fridge, flat-screen TV, and free Wi-Fi. Bathrooms have hairdryers and walk-in showers or shower/tub combos. Some rooms have special touches like vaulted ceilings, tile floors, fireplaces, and porches. Of particular note are the Hemingway room, which has a walk-in shower with six showerheads; the Frangipani room, with a whirlpool tub and porch; and the Delaney Suite, with full kitchen and barbecue deck.

See More Rooms

Features

Free breakfast and happy hour, tropical outdoor pool, concierge services, and bike rentals

Breakfast is free and plentiful, with various homemade muffins and cakes, fresh fruit, bagels, toast, and cereal. Daily happy hour includes margaritas on the house. An outdoor pool is surrounded by tropical landscaping, providing a bit of shade for guests lounging on the deck. A rear porch, also furnished with patio furniture, overlooks the pool. The owners and staff, on request, will provide concierge services, suggesting walking/running paths, booking tours, or making reservations. Bicycles are also available to rent. On-site parking is available, though limited, and there is street parking for a daily fee. 

See More Features

Oyster Hotel Review

The Conch House Heritage Inn

Scene

Historic property in Old Town with antique furnishings and a sophisticated yet warm ambiance

Built in the 19th century, The Conch House Heritage Inn is operated by direct descendants of original Key West settlers --the great-grandchildren of an island grocer who helped ship provisions to Cuban revolutionists. The hosts' warm hospitality draws repeat guests who are mainly couples, as no children under 12 are allowed. The property comprises two white clapboard siding houses with black shutters, and there's a lovely front porch with rocking chairs where guests can kick back. Palm trees and tropical plants fill the grounds and shade the outdoor pool area, where there are lounge chairs and wooden Adirondack chairs. Interiors are quietly sophisticated with glistening wood floors, antique wood furnishings, richly patterned fabrics, gilt mirrors, colorful paintings, and ceiling fans. Guests check in at the antique wood reception desk, situated in a breezy room with historic photos on the walls and a large woven rug. Throughout the interior spaces are unique chandeliers and fresh flowers, furthering the elegant yet homey vibe. 

See More Scene

Location

Ideally situated just off Duval Street in Old Town Key West

This ideally located inn sits on Truman Avenue in Old Town Key West, just a few minutes' walk from popular Duval Street -- and a block away from popular dessert restaurant, Better Than Sex. Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum is a five-minute walk, and Mallory Square is a 20-minute walk. Guests will find a CVS, shops, restaurants, bars, and other inns lining the immediate streets. Key West International Airport is a 10-minute drive.

See More Location

Rooms

Comfy rooms with antiques and flat-screen TVs; some have balconies or porches

Rooms are in the main house, poolside cottage, or poolside cabana. All are individually decorated with wood antique furnishings. One room has an island feel, with wicker chairs and brightly colored oil paintings, while another is classic and more traditional, with a wood four-poster bed, crystal chandelier, and marble end tables. Each is air-conditioned and has a mini-fridge, flat-screen TV, and free Wi-Fi. Bathrooms have hairdryers and walk-in showers or shower/tub combos. Some rooms have special touches like vaulted ceilings, tile floors, fireplaces, and porches. Of particular note are the Hemingway room, which has a walk-in shower with six showerheads; the Frangipani room, with a whirlpool tub and porch; and the Delaney Suite, with full kitchen and barbecue deck.

See More Rooms

Features

Free breakfast and happy hour, tropical outdoor pool, concierge services, and bike rentals

Breakfast is free and plentiful, with various homemade muffins and cakes, fresh fruit, bagels, toast, and cereal. Daily happy hour includes margaritas on the house. An outdoor pool is surrounded by tropical landscaping, providing a bit of shade for guests lounging on the deck. A rear porch, also furnished with patio furniture, overlooks the pool. The owners and staff, on request, will provide concierge services, suggesting walking/running paths, booking tours, or making reservations. Bicycles are also available to rent. On-site parking is available, though limited, and there is street parking for a daily fee. 

See More Features

Best Rates

Amenities

  • Air Conditioner

  • Balcony / Terrace / Patio

  • Basic Television

  • Cabanas

  • Cable

  • Concierge

  • Free Breakfast

  • Full Kitchen

  • Internet

  • Kids Allowed

  • Pool

  • Poolside Drink Service

Disclaimer: This content was accurate at the time the hotel was reviewed. Please check our partner sites when booking to verify that details are still correct.