Room Mate Grace Rating: 3.5 Pearls
Times Square, Manhattan, New York City

Oyster Review Summary

Photos and Review by Oyster.com Investigators

Pros

Cons

  • Base-level rooms are a little cramped.
  • Wednesday pool parties can get loud and run late.
  • Pricey cocktails at the swim-up bar
  • No restaurant or room service
  • Some bathrooms don't have separate shower stalls, just a curtain.

Bottom Line

For the price, this colorful 139-room Times Square boutique hotel offers more: great beds; free Wi-Fi; excellent healthy breakfasts; free access to sauna, steam room, gym; great rates on four-person rooms; and a small indoor lobby pool and swim-up bar that hosts a popular gay pool party every Wednesday.

Oyster Awards

We investigate in person.
Like your mother-in-law.

Categories

Oyster Hotel Photos

View All 10 Albums

Customers Who Viewed Room Mate Grace Also Viewed

Row NYC
19% viewed
Row NYC
Times Square, Manhattan
Warwick New York Hotel
19% viewed
Warwick New York Hotel
Midtown West, Manhattan
Sanctuary Hotel
19% viewed
Sanctuary Hotel
Times Square, Manhattan
Crowne Plaza Hotel Times Square Manhattan
19% viewed
Crowne Plaza Hotel Times Square Manhattan
Times Square, Manhattan

Oyster Hotel Review

 Scene

Pulling in families and deal-seekers with quad bunk beds and great continental breakfasts, this stylish 139-room Spanish boutique (former Hotel QT) is also known for its Wednesday night gay pool party.

Zebra-striped wallpaper in the hallways
Zebra-striped wallpaper in the hallways

Formerly Andre Balazs' Hotel QT, the 139-room Room Mate Grace boutique hotel picks up where the previous inhabitant left off: welcoming budget-minded tourists who want affordable rooms near Times Square and a fun party atmosphere where they can mingle at the 24-hour pool and swim-up bar. Add in an excellent European-style continental breakfast that runs daily and you'd be hard-pressed to get this much from a hotel elsewhere in Times Square, at this low a price.

Reminiscent of a "stylish European hostel" -- according to the New York Times -- the hotel offers a front desk kiosk that doubles as reception desk and gift shop, selling snacks, magazines, and liquor. The smallish rooms feature showers that are just separated from the toilet by a single screen or curtain, and occasionally curtains in lieu of full closet doors. These are not the most luxurious rooms you'll find in Manhattan, but the cute modish decor helps -- as do the big platform beds with Egyptian cotton linens, and the free HBO, Showtime, and Wi-Fi.

The current owners, the Madrid-based Room Mate hotel group, left much of the old Hotel QT's one-of-a-kind design in place when it took over -- and indeed, why would you mess with something as fantastic as a pool in the lobby with Greek amphitheater-style seating and a swim-up bar. Renovations were limited to more minor changes like pool furniture and unabashedly bold wallpaper. Hotel QT's somber gray hallways are now transformed into alternating floors of zebra stripes, Jonathan Adler gold-and-orange prints, and gold-flecked disco ball subtlety.

Of course, the hotel's name needs some explaining. Every Room Mate hotel carries the name of an imaginary person -- in this case, "Grace." Grace, the blond international concert performer shown on the hotel's website, is supposed to embody a New York friend that welcomes you to stay at her place. But Grace should really have been a glam drag queen or a fit dude who can do justice to a Speedo because the Room Mate Grace's big event every week is Drip, a packed gay pool party held every Wednesday night at the lobby pool, where a sea of drag queens and buff gay guys squeeze into a four-foot-deep pool with oversize rubber duckies -- security guards need to man the sauna and steam room. It's one of the best hotel parties in New York -- but if you're looking for a little peace and quiet, avoid this place on Wednesday, or at least request a room on the 4th floor or higher.

 Service

Bare bones -- what you'd expect for the low price.

Room Mate Grace, much like a European hostel, is a self-service affair.

  • Laundry service and wake-up calls
  • No room service -- every room's hotel directory comes with a stack of delivery menus from area restaurants
  • No lifeguard at the pool
  • Front-desk clerk sits behind a kiosk and also sells snacks, newspapers, and toiletries.
  • No concierge; the kiosk salesperson/hotel receptionist also doubles as de facto concierge, offering suggestions on places to eat and drink, and can also organize babysitting services.

 Location

Half-block from Times Square attractions, but on a quieter side street so you can get some sleep

Located on West 45th Street, Room Mate Grace is just a half-block away from the heart of Times Square, but it's not so close that guests can't get a decent night's rest. Though once seedy, Times Square was reborn in the mid-'90s as a commercialized tourist haven, lit by 24-hour flashing billboards and theme restaurants like ESPN Zone and Bubba Gump Shrimp. Today, visitors walking the streets are more likely to be accosted by a comedy-club promoter, a rickshaw bicycle operator, or a caricature artist than a mugger. (It also helps that there's a huge police station smack in the center of Times Square.) It's crowded, but there's something unquestionably exhilarating -- and convenient -- about staying in the neon-lit heart of the city. Plus, the mayor recently decided to close off much of Broadway to traffic, making it even more pedestrian-friendly.

 Rooms

Small, but with comfy beds and free HBO and Wi-Fi

The Petite Room
The Petite Room

While the standard "Petite" room is tiny, the toiletries are cloyingly scented, and the bathrooms are eerily reminiscent of a youth hostel, the space-maximizing rooms with bunk beds -- similar to those at the style-on-a-budget Pod Hotel -- are a great way for families or groups to save some cash.

  • Petite rooms (190 square feet) are small, even for a NYC hotel room. Some don't even have closets; just a few hangers on a bathroom hook.
  • Standard rooms (220 square feet ) come with a single queen bed, two twins (to sleep two), or two bunk beds (to sleep up to four, with individual TVs for each bed -- also called Quad Bunks)
  • Deluxe rooms (255 square feet) come with a single king, or a single bunk suspended above a king-size bed (to sleep up to three, also called King Bunks)
  • Comfy beds, well above standards in this price range -- 100-percent Egyptian cotton sheets; pillowtop mattress; four down pillows
  • Blackout shades shield rooms from the neon lights.
  • 23-inch Phillips flat-screen HDTV (small for a normal hotel room, but just fine in a tiny Petite room); DVD player; 53 channels plus free HBO and Showtime
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • iHome iPod docking clock radio
  • Empty mini-fridges (to stock with snacks and drinks from the downstairs kiosk)
  • Serviceable, but minimal, bathrooms (especially in the cheaper rooms) -- my Petite just had a toilet on one end, and a rainfall showerhead and drain on the other -- you just draw the curtain when showering
  • Two green apples served as part snack, part color compliment to the adorably packaged toiletries with a SweeTart scent -- I felt like I was rubbing Sour Patch Kids into my hair.

 Features

More for your money, from a 24-hour pool to free Wi-Fi

24-hour pool features a swim-up bar
24-hour pool features a swim-up bar
  • Four-foot-deep, 24-hour pool with club lights and a pricey swim-up bar ($16 lychee martini) -- but it's the only swim-up bar in the city
  • Popular Wednesday night gay pool party, Drip; other parties from time to time on Thursday and Friday nights
  • Free sauna and steam room
  • Small 24-hour gym -- just two Precor exercise bikes and a weight bench, some old weights, two exercise balls and a few mats. Its red-tinted window casts a red glow in the room, so it feels like you're working out in a placenta.
  • Free Wi-Fi throughout hotel
  • Two Internet stations with Dell computers near the front desk

 Family

A great deal for families, with breakfast and rooms that sleep four

Quad Bunk Room sleeps four
Quad Bunk Room sleeps four

With an excellent continental breakfasts and affordable rooms that sleep four, there's much to recommend here for families.

  • Four-foot-deep pool in the lobby
  • Quad Bunk room has two bunk beds and sleeps four; King Bunk has a king bed and a twin-size loft bed above it and sleeps three.
  • No on-site restaurant; kid-friendly food options abound within a few-block radius.
  • Free cribs

 Pets

Pets allowed, but a weight limit and deposit apply

Pets are allowed, but there is a weight limit and one-time deposit.

 Cleanliness

Overall, very clean hotel.

The pool looked murky, but not so bad that people wouldn't swim in it; given the swim-up bar, plenty of drinks get spilled in there.

 Food

No restaurant, but the European-style continental breakfast buffet is one of the best in the city

Continental breakfast every morning
Continental breakfast every morning
  • Breakfast every morning, for a charge
  • No on-site restaurant
  • No room service; room directories include a stack of delivery menus from solid area restaurants like Virgil's BBQ and John's Pizzeria.

 Bottom Line

For the price, this colorful 139-room Times Square boutique hotel offers more: great beds; free Wi-Fi; excellent healthy breakfasts; free access to sauna, steam room, gym; great rates on four-person rooms; and a small indoor lobby pool and swim-up bar that hosts a popular gay pool party every Wednesday.

Things You Should Know About Room Mate Grace

Address

  • 125 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036

Hotel Is Also Known As...

  • Hotel Qt New York
  • Qt Hotel New York
  • Room Mate Grace Hotel

Room Types

  • Deluxe 3 People Room
  • Deluxe Room
  • Petite Room
  • Premium Room
  • Standard Room
  • Standard Room 2 Beds
  • Standard Room 4 People

Enter dates for best prices

Check-in
Check-out
Guests
 AVG/NIGHT 
Hotels.com  
Expedia.com  
Tingo.com  
Booking.com  
Travelocity  
Otel.com  
Priceline.com  
CheapTickets.com  

All About Oyster

You Can't Return a Bad Vacation.

Our special investigators visit, photograph, review and rate each hotel. We uncover the truth, before it's "uh-oh" time.

Go undercover with an Oyster Investigator The Today Show
Go Undercover with an Oyster Investigator
See 56 Videos of Oyster on TV

Nearby Hotels to Consider

Night Hotel New York
Night Hotel New York
New York City, New York
Rating: 40 Pearls

Distance: Less than 0.1 mi
Hotel St. James
Hotel St. James
Midtown West, Manhattan
Rating: 25 Pearls

Distance: Less than 0.1 mi
The Premier
The Premier
Times Square, Manhattan
Rating: 40 Pearls

Distance: Less than 0.1 mi
Broadway at Times Square Hotel
Broadway at Times Square Hotel
Times Square, Manhattan
Rating: 25 Pearls

Distance: Less than 0.1 mi

Hotel Features

Number of Rooms: 140
Pool: Yes
Internet: Yes
Cribs: Yes
View All

Hotel Information

Location: Times Square, Manhattan
Address: 125 West 45th Street, New York, NY 10036
(See Map)
Loading Live Rates
Loading...