Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina Rating: 3.0 Pearls
Montauk, The Hamptons, Long Island

Oyster Review Summary

Photos and Review by Oyster.com Investigators

Pros

  • Two lovely outdoor pools and one indoor pool
  • A nice variety of restaurants and bars on-site
  • Free shuttles to Montauk Harbor, downtown, and beaches
  • A spa and salon on-site, plus modern fitness center, and saunas
  • Each room comes with a balcony or terrace, plus iPod docks
  • Outdoor tennis courts and tennis pro on-site
  • Free use of beach cruiser bikes
  • Charter boat trips that leave from marina
  • Free Wi-Fi and parking

Cons

  • High prices during the summer season
  • The outdoor pool and beach areas can get crowded with kids
  • The location is not walking distance to the ocean or town
  • Rooms have been renovated but some areas need updating

Bottom Line

This family-friendly resort has a variety of renovated rooms, suites, and villas overlooking Lake Montauk. The views take advantage of the attached marina, bobbing with boats galore, and are crowned by a white lighthouse. The resort has more than 80 years of intriguing history, and rooms are pricey but nicely decorated in nautical style. Though the location is not directly on the ocean, on-site activities and restaurants, and the free shuttles to town make it a draw for an amenities-filled Hamptons getaway.

Oyster Awards

We investigate in person.
Like your mother-in-law.

Categories

,

Oyster Hotel Photos

View All 11 Albums

Customers Who Viewed Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina Also Viewed

Panoramic View
33% viewed
Panoramic View
Montauk, The Hamptons
Sole East
33% viewed
Sole East
Montauk, The Hamptons

Oyster Hotel Review

 Scene

A family-friendly resort with a variety of activities and restaurants

Beach at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina
Beach at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina

This expansive and historic resort evokes another time. Originally built in 1928 by entrepreneur Carl Fisher (the man credited with turning Miami from a sleepy backwater town to a thriving resort metropolis), the resort quickly became the local go-to vacation destination for the wealthy (original members of the club include J.P. Morgan, Vincent Astor, and Harold S. Vanderbilt). Charles Lindbergh is said to have often flown his seaplane into the harbor to dock at the club's marina. And according to local legend, the Island Club (which was located next door to the original resort and would eventually become part of the resort as it stands today), was the most popular speakeasy and gambling casino around town during Prohibition. To avoid trouble, the club posted sentries at the stone stanchions at the end of the island's causeway -- when the police stopped by, the sentries would radio the club for management to hide the liquor and gambling equipment.

Today, the resort maintains some of that storied appeal (the towering white lighthouse is what beaconed guests to the resort from its inception). Yet there are plenty of modernized amenities to keep today's guest happy -- though the two outdoor pools and small private beach are popular with kids, so if you’re looking for some celebrity-style peace and quiet, head to the ocean. Despite updates and upgrades, one original trait has remained consistent through the years: The resort, as a whole, attracts a wealthy set, and guests shouldn't be surprised to see the occasional celebrity roaming its grounds.

 Location

Minutes from Montauk Harbor, the resort faces a marina, and is a short drive from the ocean and downtown

At the easternmost tip of Long Island, the Montauk Yacht Club’s lakeside location is kitty corner from Montauk Harbor -- an area containing restaurants, shops, plenty of harborside sightseeing. In addition to downtown Montauk, there are many nearby towns to explore, and, of course, miles of sandy beaches to enjoy.

  • 84-minute drive to Islip Airport
  • 4-minute drive to Montauk Harbor
  • 9-minute drive to downtown Montauk and beaches
  • 10-minute drive to Montauk Point
  • 22-minute drive to East Hampton
  • 34-minute drive to Sag Harbor
  • 40-minute drive to Southampton
  • 150-minute drive to Manhattan

 Rooms

Renovated nautical-style rooms, suites, and villas appeal to the just-off-the-boat or jitney haute summer crowd

The Admiral Class Water View Room at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina
The Admiral Class Water View Room at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina

The 107 rooms and suites at the Montauk Yacht Club -- not surprisingly -- are decorated in nautical style, with splashes of navy blue against white. The villas are housed separately from the main buildings, and are more spacious and modern. Villas don’t have their own private balconies or terraces, but they have access to lawn space with tables and chairs.

  • Comfortable 300-thread count sheets, duvets, and goose-down pillows
  • Balcony or terrace (views range so make sure to ask in advance), except in the villas
  • Keurig coffeemakers with free coffee; mini-fridges
  • iPod docks and large flat-screen TVs
  • Bath products by L’Occitane during high season
  • Standard shower/tub combos

 Features

Tennis courts, yoga classes, and a hopping nightlife scene make this a fun summer resort

Sauna at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina
Sauna at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina

 Food

A range of high-end cuisine, specialty cocktails, and casual bar bites make it easy to stay close

Hurricane Alley at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina
Hurricane Alley at the Montauk Yacht Club Resort & Marina

Montauk Yacht Club offers a good mix of dining options that appeal to both families and couples seeking romance.

  • The Gulf Coast Kitchen is a higher-end New American restaurant that focuses on local ingredients.
  • The more casual Hurricane Alley has a Florida feel and offers both indoor and outdoor seating.
  • Barracuda Bar is an indoor nautical-style lounge offering specialty cocktails and small bites.
  • The Turtle Lounge is another nautical-style area to enjoy a pre-dinner drink.

 Bottom Line

This family-friendly resort has a variety of renovated rooms, suites, and villas overlooking Lake Montauk. The views take advantage of the attached marina, bobbing with boats galore, and are crowned by a white lighthouse. The resort has more than 80 years of intriguing history, and rooms are pricey but nicely decorated in nautical style. Though the location is not directly on the ocean, on-site activities and restaurants, and the free shuttles to town make it a draw for an amenities-filled Hamptons getaway.

Find the Lowest Price - Enter Dates

Check-in
Check-out
Guests
Compare rates on dozens of sites
 AVG/NIGHT 
Hotels.com  
Expedia.com  
Tingo.com  
Booking.com  
Travelocity  
Otel.com  
Priceline.com  
CheapTickets.com  

All About Oyster

You Can't Return a Bad Vacation.

Our special investigators visit, photograph, review and rate each hotel. We uncover the truth, before it's "uh-oh" time.

Go undercover with an Oyster Investigator The Today Show
Go Undercover with an Oyster Investigator
See 70 Videos of Oyster on TV

Nearby Hotels to Consider

Sole East
  • Sole East
  • Montauk, The Hamptons
  • Rating: 40 Pearls
  • Distance: 2.7 mi
Panoramic View
  • Panoramic View
  • Montauk, The Hamptons
  • Rating: 40 Pearls
  • Distance: 5.0 mi
Sea Crest on the Ocean
Ocean Dunes Resort & Residences

Hotel Features

Number of Rooms: 106
Pool: Yes
Fitness Center: Yes
Internet Access: Yes
Cribs: Yes
View All

Hotel Information

Location: Montauk, The Hamptons
Address: 32 Star Island Road
(See Map)
Loading Live Rates
Loading...