Koa Kea Resort Hotel at Poipu Beach Rating: 4.5 Pearls
Kauai, Hawaii, United States

Oyster Review Summary

Photos and Review by Oyster.com Investigators

Pros

Cons

  • Only a single upscale restaurant and lounge
  • Only one small, shallow pool
  • Pricier than some of the mega-resorts on the island, yet with fewer features
  • $15.62 daily resort fee

Bottom Line

This 121-room Poipu boutique hotel offers five-star features -- rooms with fine Egyptian linens, Italian marble bathrooms, and personal espresso machines, and a free fitness center with individual cable-TV monitors. With just one pool and restaurant, it lacks the extras of the mega-resorts -- but the service is more attentive and pampering.

Oyster Awards

We investigate in person.
Like your mother-in-law.

Categories

, , , ,

Oyster Hotel Photos

View All 9 Albums

Customers Who Viewed Koa Kea Resort Hotel at Poipu Beach Also Viewed

Lotus Honolulu at Diamond Head
23% viewed
Lotus Honolulu at Diamond Head
Diamond Head, Honolulu
Sheraton Maui Resort
18% viewed
Sheraton Maui Resort
Maui, Hawaii
Sheraton Kauai Resort
14% viewed
Sheraton Kauai Resort
Kauai, Hawaii

Oyster Hotel Review

 Scene

An alternative to Poipu's mega-resorts and condos, this small boutique has attentive five-star service and luxurious rooms.

The hotel's sleek lobby
The hotel's sleek lobby

An intimate, boutique-hotel alternative to the multitude of condos and mega-resorts dotting the Poipu coastline, the 121-room Koa Kea is a hidden gem: The motel-like exterior masks a slickly designed lobby and fine Pacific Rim restaurant, fitness center with new Cybex equipment, and luxurious rooms with 42-inch plasma TVs, sumptuous Anichini linens, and espresso machines.

The former site of the budget Poipu Beach Hotel (devastated by Hurricane Iniki in 1992), 121-room Koa Kea is actually the old Poipu Beach Hotel exterior, completely gutted and redone inside. Under current building ordinances, the owners would have had to build further back from the coastline if they had ripped down the old hotel. By sticking with the old building, Koa Kea was able to remain one of the closest hotels to the beach -- about 25 yards away from the water (much closer than neighboring Marriott Waiohai). The beach is pretty much the same stretch as Kiahuna Plantation's: good for snorkeling and surfing, but with plenty of rocks that are easy for swimmers to cut their feet on as they're pulled with the strong current.

It does feel like you're driving up to an old, signless motel next to the splashier Marriott. But two steps into the sleek white-leather-couch lobby -- done by the same designer behind Vegas' Red Rock and Four Seasons -- and you've entered a completely different hotel. Twenty-four-hour porters whisk your bags away, and a front desk receptionist escorts you to your room, showing you how to use your Nespresso machine. A half hour later, and a staff member came to my door with a letter welcoming me to the hotel and three types of macadamia nuts. This is the kind of five-star pampering you'd find at the Four Seasons Maui -- turndown service, twice-daily housekeeping -- but it's pretty much nonexistent on Kauai's south shore (even at the fancy Grand Hyatt).

Those expecting the expansive list of features that's common in this price range (the Sheraton Kauai mega-resort, just down the street, runs a third less) will be disappointed by Koa Kea's single pool and restaurant. But offering an endless number of features is not the focus of Koa Kea, which falls into the boutique hotel niche rather than the full-on resort category. Koa Kea is for those seeking a lavishly stylish but intimate experience that's less overwhelming than staying at the 602-room Grand Hyatt, considered the most extravagant resort on the island. Koa Kea also offers much more personal, attentive service.

 Service

Hard to beat, with personal room escorts, twice-daily housekeeping, and turndown service

Porters are on call 24 hours.
Porters are on call 24 hours.

Guests at the Koa Kea can expect attentive five-star service, even better than what you'll get at the pricier Grand Hyatt.

  • Porters on duty 24 hours a day
  • Front desk staffer escorts guests to room
  • Nightly turndown service with bottle of water by the bed
  • Twice-daily housekeeping
  • 24-hour room service
  • Valet parking
  • Concierge
  • Poolside food and drink service

 Location

30 minutes from the Lihue Airport, in the middle of the south shore Poipu resort area

Koa Kea is in Poipu, the south shore development that's one of Kauai's biggest resort areas. The town is known for its consistently sunny weather (versus the rainy north shore), picturesque, treelined streets -- and constant construction as developers add more condominiums and hotels to these former sugarcane fields. Located just off Poipu Road, the main strip flanked by resorts on one side and a shopping mall on the other, Koa Kea shares an entrance and beach with the Marriott Waiohai and Kiahuna Plantation.

  • On family friendly Kiahuna beach, whose clear water is perfect for snorkeling and gentle waves are good for surfing lessons
  • Minutes away from Waiohai Beach, where more experienced surfers can find larger waves.
  • Across the street from Poipu Shopping Village, with affordable restaurants including Keoki's Paradise and Puka Dog and fine dining like Roy's
  • Five-minute drive to Spouting Horn, a lava rock formation that shoots water 50 feet into the air
  • 15 miles, 30 minutes from Lihue Airport, Kauai's main airport
  • Two hours from the scenic, undeveloped Na Pali Coast on the north shore, popular for hiking and kayaking
  • 90 minutes from stunning Waimea Canyon, the largest canyon in the Pacific
  • Near highly regarded Kiahuna Golf Club and Poipu Bay Golf Course

 Rooms

Small but luxurious, with modern decor and luxury amenities

The standard room
The standard room

Confined by the framework of the original hotel, Koa Kea's rooms are smaller than those at the Grand Hyatt (442 square feet versus Hyatt's 500). But they're done up with a cozy, modern boutique-style decor (versus Hyatt's quaint plantation-style) and offer a few more luxury amenities, including 42-inch flat-screens and a drawer hiding an easy-to-use espresso machine (but no bathtub -- just a marble shower with a bench). Westin Princeville's one and two-bedroom condos still have both beat, though -- in size and amenities.

  • Fresh, modern decor: sleek dark-wood furnishings with turquoise accent pillows, and shelves holding fresh coral and seashells
  • Room rates vary by view; ocean-front rooms lie very close to the water, but can be more than $300 extra a night versus standard garden view.
  • One-bedroom suites: 720 square feet; two-bedroom suites are one-bedroom suites with a connecting guest room
  • L'Occitane toiletries
  • iPod-compatible stereos
  • Free Wi-Fi
  • Extraordinarily comfortable beds: pillow-topped Simmons Beautyrest mattress covered in a thick featherbed, Anichini Egyptian cotton sheets, a white-goose down duvet and four oversize down pillows
  • Cable with 48 stations, including HBO. Pay-per-view high def: $14.95. Non HD: $12.95
  • Cotton waffle-knit robes, Turkish cotton towels, Egyptian cotton sheets, all from custom luxury linen company Anichini

 Features

Low on features (one small pool), and $15.62 daily resort fee

No waterslide or games to divert the kids
No waterslide or games to divert the kids

As an intimate, 121-room luxury boutique hotel, Koa Kea isn't rich with the same extensive features that the Grand Hyatt or even the cheaper Sheraton Kauai have (multiple pools, several restaurants, a kids' club). Koa Kea's small pool and two-computer business center can't really hold a candle to what you'll find at these larger resorts.

  • Only one small, slightly kidney-shaped pool with Jacuzzi; no children's pool
  • Poolside wait service from poolside bar that serves tropical cocktails and three types of panini
  • Five-treatment-room spa that's small but offers an extensive selection of massages, facials, and waxing, including Kauai adventure-specific treatments (massages after a day of hiking, body treatments after a sunburn)
  • Small fitness center with windows (looking out onto the parking lot, unfortunately)
  • New equipment: All Cybex cardio machines (five treadmills, two ellipticals, two upright bikes) with TV monitors with cable; Iron Grip weights, but no strength-training machines
  • Business center is free (to surf and print), but it's just two cubicles with computers, awkwardly located in the hotel's administrative offices.
  • Faxing costs extra ($2.50 to $5 for first page, $.50 to $1 each additional page).

 Beach

Shares Kiahuna Beach, a narrow crescent-shaped stretch of sand, with several other vacation properties

The gentle waves are swimmer friendly.
The gentle waves are swimmer friendly.

One of the most family-friendly beaches in Poipu, Kiahuna Beach sits at the foot of three resort properties: Koa Kea, Kiahuna Plantation, and Sheraton Kauai. Beachgoers, predominately resort guests, take surf lessons, play in the sand, and snorkel in the clear water.

  • Clear water good for snorkeling; gentle waves good for surfing lessons and boogie boarding
  • At times waves too rough for young children
  • Rocks on the bottom are easy to cut your feet on, but for the most part it's a safe beach
  • Minutes away from Waiohai Beach, in front of the nearby Marriott Waiohai, where larger waves attract more experienced surfers, and a cove and sandbar create a shallow, sheltered pool
  • At both beaches, as is the case in nearly all of Kauai, the sand stops shortly past the shore, yielding to lava rock or reef.
  • Free beach and pool towels (pool towels are the same thick, Anichini white Turkish cotton ones found in the room)
  • Watersports hut from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. rents boogie boards, snorkels; offers surfing lessons and excursions.

 Family

Geared more toward couples than families

Snorkeling on the resort's grounds
Snorkeling on the resort's grounds

Koa Kea is a luxury boutique better suited to honeymooners than families. If you're traveling with children, try the Grand Hyatt with its impressive pools and big kids' club.

  • No children's pool; single pool has no waterslide
  • No kids' menu at restaurant or poolside bar
  • Free cribs
  • No rollaway beds

 Cleanliness

Very clean

Twice-daily housekeeping keeps the rooms sparkling, and the common areas and pools are equally spotless.

 Food

One upscale restaurant and lounge

The excellent Red Salt Lounge
The excellent Red Salt Lounge

Serving fresh seafood with Pacific Rim flavors, Koa Kea's upscale Red Salt restaurant is an elegant choice for a romantic evening. But be forewarned that these involved entrees (vanilla-seared mahi mahi with avocado ginger salsa, seared ahi with cilantro risotto) do not come cheap.

 Bottom Line

This 121-room Poipu boutique hotel offers five-star features -- rooms with fine Egyptian linens, Italian marble bathrooms, and personal espresso machines, and a free fitness center with individual cable-TV monitors. With just one pool and restaurant, it lacks the extras of the mega-resorts -- but the service is more attentive and pampering.

Things You Should Know About Koa Kea Resort Hotel at Poipu Beach

Address

  • 2251 Po'ipu Road, Koloa, HI, 96756, US

Hotel Is Also Known As...

  • Koa Kea Hotel
  • Koa Kea Resort

Room Types

  • Garden View Room
  • Oceanfront Room
  • Oceanfront Suite
  • Ocean View Room
  • Ocean View Suite
  • Partial Ocean View Room

Find the Lowest Price - Enter Dates

Check-in
Check-out
Guests
 AVG/NIGHT 
Hotels.com  
Expedia.com  
Tingo.com  
Booking.com  
Travelocity  
Otel.com  
Priceline.com  
CheapTickets.com  

All About Oyster

You Can't Return a Bad Vacation.

Our special investigators visit, photograph, review and rate each hotel. We uncover the truth, before it's "uh-oh" time.

Go undercover with an Oyster Investigator The Today Show
Go Undercover with an Oyster Investigator
See 56 Videos of Oyster on TV

Nearby Hotels to Consider

Marriott's Waiohai Beach Club: A Marriott Vacation Club Resort
Castle Kiahuna Plantation Beach Bungalows
Outrigger Kiahuna Plantation
Sheraton Kauai Resort

Hotel Features

Number of Rooms: 121
Pool: N/A
Fitness Center: Yes
Spa: Yes
Cribs: Yes
Jacuzzi (in room): N/A
View All

Hotel Information

Location: Kauai, Hawaii
Address: 2251 Po'ipu Road, Koloa, HI, 96756, US
(See Map)
Loading Live Rates
Loading...